35 COTTER ST
Valuation
Tax & Assessment
Property Facts
Transaction History(3)
Sales and refinances filed with the county for this home. Not every transfer is a normal sale, so check the type before comparing prices.Assigned SchoolsThe public schools this address is zoned for. Boundaries change, so confirm with the district before you count on it.
District: West Islip Union Free School District
Neighborhood · ZIP 11795These are comparison scores, not percentages. 100 equals the national average, so 150 means about 50% above average.
Index scale: 100 = US average (tick). Lower is better.
Owner Tools
Data by ATTOM. Valuations are automated estimates, not appraisals. Photos from Google Street View and may not depict the current property state.
How this home compares
35 Cotter St measured against every home in its neighborhood, its ZIP code and its county, using county assessor records refreshed nightly. A home can stand out in one of those areas and look ordinary in another, because each one holds a different mix of homes.
- Worth more than 83% of homes in West Islip 11795
What homes are worth in West Islip 11795
Each bar is how many homes fall in that price range. The marker is this home.
This home is worth more than 83% of homes in West Islip 11795.
How it measures up in West Islip 11795
The dot is this home. The mark in the middle is the typical home in West Islip 11795.
Pricier than 83% of homes nearby
Bigger than 60% of homes nearby
| Measure | This home | West Islip 11795 | Suffolk County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimated valuepricier than | $946,293 | 83% of homes | 76% of homes |
| Lot sizebigger than | 0.25 ac | 60% of homes | 46% of homes |
About 35 Cotter St
How much is 35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY worth?
The TopHap Estimate for 35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY is $946,293 as of Oct 21, 2026. The likely range is $856,206 to $1,036,380. The estimate is modelled from recorded sales, assessments and the property's own characteristics — it is not an appraisal.
When did 35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY last sell?
35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY last sold on Sep 16, 2011 for $535,000, according to the county's recorded deed. TopHap holds 3 recorded sales for this parcel.
What schools serve 35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY?
35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY is assigned to Manetuck Elementary School (elementary), rated C-; Udall Road Middle School (middle), rated A-; West Islip High School (high), rated A-. All sit in West Islip Union Free School District. Attendance boundaries change — confirm with the district before relying on an assignment.
How does 35 Cotter St, West Islip, NY compare to other homes in West Islip 11795?
Among the 8,123 homes in West Islip 11795, it is worth more than 83% of them ($946,293 against a typical $704,206) and its lot is bigger than 60% of them (0.25 ac against a typical 0.25 ac). Measured against all of Suffolk County, it is worth more than 76% of homes there. These shares are recounted nightly from the full county assessor record for each area, not from active listings.
More homes on Cotter St
- 85 Cotter St$725K988 ft² · Sold $715K · Jul 2026
- 84 Cotter St$679K1,278 ft² · Sold $600K · Oct 2024
- 27 Cotter St$785K0.25 ac · Sold $688K · Apr 2024
- 30 Cotter St$793K0.25 ac · Sold $668K · Feb 2023
- 34 Cotter St$880K0.25 ac · Sold $825K · Dec 2022
- 4 Cotter St$670K1,473 ft² · Sold $380K · Jun 2019
- 92 Cotter St$760K1,848 ft² · Sold $450K · May 2018
- 22 Cotter St$718K0.25 ac · Sold $390K · Mar 2017
- 64 Cotter St$647K0.25 ac · Sold $333K · Feb 2017
- 56 Cotter St$696K0.25 ac · Sold $338K · Oct 2016
- 31 Cotter St$728K0.25 ac · Sold $375K · Apr 2016
- 73 Cotter St$563K0.25 ac · Sold Mar 2011
Closest homes
- 39 Cotter St$889K75 ft · 0.25 ac · Sold $590K · Jul 2008
- 31 Cotter St$728K76 ft · 0.25 ac · Sold $375K · Apr 2016
- 43 Cotter St$583K148 ft · 0.25 ac · Sold Jan 1900
- 27 Cotter St$785K153 ft · 0.25 ac · Sold $688K · Apr 2024
- 32 Gridley St151 ft · 2,515 ft² · Sold Jan 1900
- 28 Gridley St$579K189 ft · 0.51 ac · Sold Jan 1900
- 36 Gridley St$608K169 ft · 1,092 ft² · Sold $370K · Mar 2020
- 47 Cotter St$614K220 ft · 0.25 ac · Sold $290K · Jul 2002
More homes in West Islip 11795
- 135 W 4th St$627K0.23 ac · Sold $420K · Oct 2026
- 532 Rockaway St$709K1,008 ft² · Sold $700K · Oct 2026
- 630 Oak Neck Rd$631K1,305 ft² · Sold $628K · Oct 2026
- 159 Driftwood Dr$1.2M2,620 ft² · Sold $1.2M · Oct 2026
- 849 E Bay Dr$906K0.11 ac · Sold $896K · Oct 2026
- 90 Babylon Ave$736K0.3 ac · Sold $725K · Oct 2026
- 71 Paprocki Ave$528K0.21 ac · Sold $526K · Sep 2026
- 185 W Islip Rd$1.6M3,395 ft² · Sold $2M · Sep 2026
- 67 Edgewood Rd$684K0.3 ac · Sold $675K · Sep 2026
- 96 Kobb Blvd$565K0.17 ac · Sold $448K · Sep 2026
- 205 Hyman Ave$500K1,512 ft² · Sold $440K · Sep 2026
- 44 Archie Pl$954K0.16 ac · Sold $951K · Sep 2026
Assigned schools
Explore the area
See this home in context
Open 35 Cotter St on TopHap’s interactive map to compare it against every sale nearby, overlay school zones and flood risk, and run a CMA.
Open in map