5011 RUSTIC WAY
Valuation
Tax & Assessment
Property Facts
Transaction History(2)
Sales and refinances filed with the county for this home. Not every transfer is a normal sale, so check the type before comparing prices.Assigned SchoolsThe public schools this address is zoned for. Boundaries change, so confirm with the district before you count on it.
District: McFarland School District
Neighborhood · ZIP 53558These are comparison scores, not percentages. 100 equals the national average, so 150 means about 50% above average.
Index scale: 100 = US average (tick). Lower is better.
Owner Tools
Data by ATTOM. Valuations are automated estimates, not appraisals. Photos from Google Street View and may not depict the current property state.
How this home compares
5011 Rustic Way measured against every home in its neighborhood, its ZIP code and its county, using county assessor records refreshed nightly. A home can stand out in one of those areas and look ordinary in another, because each one holds a different mix of homes.
- Costs more per square foot than 86% of homes in McFarland 53558
- Smaller than 74% of homes in McFarland 53558
- Has a bigger lot than 83% of homes in McFarland 53558
What homes are worth in McFarland 53558
Each bar is how many homes fall in that price range. The marker is this home.
This home is worth more than 54% of homes in McFarland 53558.
How it measures up in McFarland 53558
The dot is this home. The mark in the middle is the typical home in McFarland 53558.
Pricier than 54% of homes nearby
Pricier than 86% of homes nearby
Bigger than 26% of homes nearby
Bigger than 83% of homes nearby
Newer than 44% of homes nearby
| Measure | This home | McFarland 53558 | Dane County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimated valuepricier than | $468,745 | 54% of homes | 57% of homes |
| Price per ft²pricier than | $313 | 86% of homes | 77% of homes |
| Living areabigger than | 1,498 ft² | 26% of homes | 37% of homes |
| Lot sizebigger than | 0.42 ac | 83% of homes | 76% of homes |
| Year builtnewer than | 1986 | 44% of homes | 59% of homes |
About 5011 Rustic Way
How much is 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI worth?
The TopHap Estimate for 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI is $468,745 as of Oct 21, 2026. The likely range is $448,323 to $489,167. The estimate is modelled from recorded sales, assessments and the property's own characteristics — it is not an appraisal.
When did 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI last sell?
5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI last sold on Aug 3, 2022 for $422,500, according to the county's recorded deed.
How big is 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI?
5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI has 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, 1,498 square feet of living space and a 0.42-acre lot.
When was 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI built?
5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI was built in 1986, making it 40 years old. It is a contemporary home. The building has 1 story.
What schools serve 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI?
5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI is assigned to McFarland High School (high), rated A+; Conrad Elvehjem Primary School (elementary); Indian Mound Middle School (middle), rated A. All sit in McFarland School District. Attendance boundaries change — confirm with the district before relying on an assignment.
How does 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI compare to other homes in McFarland 53558?
Among the 4,735 homes in McFarland 53558, it is worth more than 54% of them ($468,745 against a typical $453,411), its price per square foot is higher than 86% of them ($313 against a typical $237), it is bigger than 26% of them (1,498 ft² against a typical 1,872 ft²), its lot is bigger than 83% of them (0.42 ac against a typical 0.26 ac) and it is newer than 44% of them (1986 against a typical 1990). Measured against all of Dane County, it is worth more than 57% of homes there. These shares are recounted nightly from the full county assessor record for each area, not from active listings.
What are the property taxes on 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI?
The 2025 property tax bill for 5011 Rustic Way, Mcfarland, WI was $7,725. The county assessed it at $479,500.
More homes on Rustic Way
- 5009 Rustic Way$459K3 bd · 2 ba · 1,463 ft² · Sold $450K · Aug 2025
- 5012 Rustic Way$631K4 bd · 3 ba · 2,752 ft² · Sold $615K · May 2025
- 5204 Rustic Way$517K3 bd · 3 ba · 2,064 ft² · Sold Dec 2024
- 5102 Rustic Way$672K3 bd · 3 ba · 2,888 ft² · Sold Jan 2022
- 5110 Rustic Way$478K4 bd · 3 ba · 2,214 ft² · Sold $395K · Jan 2022
- 5007 Rustic Way$690K4 bd · 4 ba · 2,430 ft² · Sold $464K · Sep 2019
- 5207 Rustic Way$559K3 bd · 3 ba · 1,944 ft² · Sold $280K · Feb 2016
- 5202 Rustic Way$522K4 bd · 3 ba · 1,992 ft² · Sold $296K · Apr 2015
- 5101 Rustic Way$796K3 bd · 4 ba · 3,340 ft² · Sold $350K · Aug 2013
- 5108 Rustic Way$504K3 bd · 3 ba · 2,796 ft² · Sold $232K · May 2013
- 5210 Rustic Way$642K0.6 ac · Sold Jul 2009
- 5010 Rustic Way$604K4 bd · 2 ba · 2,134 ft²
Closest homes
- 5101 Rustic Way$796K98 ft · 3 bd · 4 ba · 3,340 ft² · Sold $350K · Aug 2013
- 5009 Rustic Way$459K104 ft · 3 bd · 2 ba · 1,463 ft² · Sold $450K · Aug 2025
- 5105 Rustic Way$647K195 ft · 4 bd · 4 ba · 2,454 ft²
- 5007 Rustic Way$690K224 ft · 4 bd · 4 ba · 2,430 ft² · Sold $464K · Sep 2019
- 5104 Valley Dr$674K195 ft · 4 bd · 4 ba · 2,670 ft² · Sold $592K · Jun 2023
- 5010 Valley Dr$601K189 ft · 4 bd · 3 ba · 2,527 ft²
- 5106 Valley Dr$634K237 ft · 3 bd · 4 ba · 2,994 ft² · Sold $475K · Jun 2021
- 5008 Valley Dr$637K224 ft · 4 bd · 3 ba · 2,896 ft² · Sold $395K · Oct 2020
More homes in Mcfarland 53558
- 5960 Oak Hollow Dr$995K5 bd · 4.5 ba · 4,701 ft² · Sold $950K · Nov 2026
- 6001 Osborn Dr$340K2 bd · 2 ba · 1,092 ft² · Sold $340K · Nov 2026
- 5608 Osborn Dr$410K3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,249 ft² · Sold $415K · Nov 2026
- 6014 Johnson St$290K4 bd · 2 ba · 2,096 ft² · Sold $280K · Nov 2026
- 5526 Prairie Place Dr$329K2.25 ac · Sold $317K · Nov 2026
- 5410 Chestnut Ln$473K3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,686 ft² · Sold $465K · Nov 2026
- 5310 Broadhead St$289K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,335 ft² · Sold $280K · Nov 2026
- 4727 Catalina Pkwy$600K4 bd · 3 ba · 2,684 ft² · Sold $570K · Nov 2026
- 2645 Us Highway 51$205K0.59 ac · Sold Oct 2026
- 5919 Rosewood Dr$580K0.16 ac · Sold $580K · Oct 2026
- 5867 Holscher Rd$371K2 bd · 2 ba · 1,502 ft² · Sold $368K · Oct 2026
- 3614 Bittner Ln$450K0.44 ac · Sold $476K · Oct 2026
Assigned schools
Explore the area
See this home in context
Open 5011 Rustic Way on TopHap’s interactive map to compare it against every sale nearby, overlay school zones and flood risk, and run a CMA.
Open in map