5440 PILLORY WAY
Valuation
Tax & Assessment
Property Facts
Transaction History(3)
Sales and refinances filed with the county for this home. Not every transfer is a normal sale, so check the type before comparing prices.Assigned SchoolsThe public schools this address is zoned for. Boundaries change, so confirm with the district before you count on it.
District: Pike Township Metropolitan School District
Neighborhood · ZIP 46254These are comparison scores, not percentages. 100 equals the national average, so 150 means about 50% above average.
Index scale: 100 = US average (tick). Lower is better.
Owner Tools
Data by ATTOM. Valuations are automated estimates, not appraisals. Photos from Google Street View and may not depict the current property state.
How this home compares
5440 Pillory Way measured against every home in its neighborhood, its ZIP code and its county, using county assessor records refreshed nightly. A home can stand out in one of those areas and look ordinary in another, because each one holds a different mix of homes.
- Worth more than 90% of homes in Indianapolis 46254
- Costs more per square foot than 86% of homes in Indianapolis 46254
- Bigger than 65% of homes in Indianapolis 46254
- Has a bigger lot than 90% of homes in Indianapolis 46254
- Newer than 75% of homes in Marion County
What homes are worth in Indianapolis 46254
Each bar is how many homes fall in that price range. The marker is this home.
This home is worth more than 90% of homes in Indianapolis 46254.
How it measures up in Indianapolis 46254
The dot is this home. The mark in the middle is the typical home in Indianapolis 46254.
Pricier than 90% of homes nearby
Pricier than 86% of homes nearby
Bigger than 65% of homes nearby
Bigger than 90% of homes nearby
Newer than 60% of homes nearby
| Measure | This home | Indianapolis 46254 | Marion County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimated valuepricier than | $289,138 | 90% of homes | 72% of homes |
| Price per ft²pricier than | $176 | 86% of homes | 76% of homes |
| Living areabigger than | 1,644 ft² | 65% of homes | 58% of homes |
| Lot sizebigger than | 0.34 ac | 90% of homes | 77% of homes |
| Year builtnewer than | 1992 | 60% of homes | 75% of homes |
About 5440 Pillory Way
How much is 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN worth?
The TopHap Estimate for 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN is $289,138 as of Oct 21, 2026. The likely range is $259,772 to $318,504. The estimate is modelled from recorded sales, assessments and the property's own characteristics — it is not an appraisal.
When did 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN last sell?
5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN last sold on Jan 16, 2025 for $275,000, according to the county's recorded deed. TopHap holds 2 recorded sales for this parcel.
How big is 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN?
5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1,644 square feet of living space and a 0.34-acre lot.
When was 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN built?
5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN was built in 1992, making it 34 years old. The building has 2 stories.
What schools serve 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN?
5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN is assigned to Pike High School (high); Lincoln Middle School (middle), rated D-; Snacks Crossing Elementary School (elementary), rated D-. All sit in Pike Township Metropolitan School District. Attendance boundaries change — confirm with the district before relying on an assignment.
How does 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN compare to other homes in Indianapolis 46254?
Among the 9,884 homes in Indianapolis 46254, it is worth more than 90% of them ($289,138 against a typical $217,915), its price per square foot is higher than 86% of them ($176 against a typical $146), it is bigger than 65% of them (1,644 ft² against a typical 1,449 ft²), its lot is bigger than 90% of them (0.34 ac against a typical 0.16 ac) and it is newer than 60% of them (1992 against a typical 1990). Measured against all of Marion County, it is worth more than 72% of homes there. These shares are recounted nightly from the full county assessor record for each area, not from active listings.
What are the property taxes on 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN?
The 2024 property tax bill for 5440 Pillory Way, Indianapolis, IN was $2,867. The county assessed it at $255,600.
More homes on Pillory Way
- 5582 Pillory Way$205K4 bd · 2 ba · 2,008 ft² · Sold $200K · Dec 2025
- 5450 Pillory Way$253K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,530 ft² · Sold $240K · Nov 2024
- 5742 Pillory Way$226K4 bd · 2 ba · 1,650 ft² · Sold $273K · May 2024
- 5704 Pillory Way$300K4 bd · 1 ba · 2,165 ft² · Sold $296K · Dec 2022
- 5618 Pillory Way$232K4 bd · 2 ba · 1,782 ft² · Sold $160K · Jun 2022
- 5735 Pillory Way$227K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,499 ft² · Sold $250K · May 2022
- 5724 Pillory Way$223K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,662 ft² · Sold $215K · Feb 2022
- 5736 Pillory Way$254K4 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,988 ft² · Sold $106K · Dec 2020
- 5535 Pillory Way$259K4 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,942 ft² · Sold $196K · Oct 2020
- 5459 Pillory Way$213K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,246 ft² · Sold Oct 2020
- 5530 Pillory Way$219K3 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,466 ft² · Sold $165K · Aug 2019
- 5705 Pillory Way$250K3 bd · 2 ba · 2,036 ft² · Sold Apr 2019
Closest homes
- 5430 Bethesda Ln$246K119 ft · 4 bd · 2 ba · 1,874 ft² · Sold Nov 2008
- 5450 Pillory Way$253K120 ft · 3 bd · 1 ba · 1,530 ft² · Sold $240K · Nov 2024
- 5445 Pillory Way$258K178 ft · 4 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,116 ft² · Sold $138K · Aug 2017
- 5528 W 62nd St$254K234 ft · 3 bd · 1 ba · 1,362 ft²
- 6140 Pillory Dr234 ft · 4 bd · 2 ba · 2,036 ft²
- 6140 Pillory Dr237 ft · 4 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,036 ft² · Sold Jan 1900
- 6143 Pillory Dr$260K210 ft · 3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,644 ft² · Sold $179K · Sep 2021
- 5451 Pillory Way$239K226 ft · 3 bd · 1 ba · 1,534 ft²
More homes in Indianapolis 46254
- 6037 Mcclellan Ct$290K4 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,052 ft² · Sold $279K · Nov 2026
- 4606 Stansbury Ln$195K2 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,211 ft² · Sold $252K · Nov 2026
- 6350 Apache Dr$200K3 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,332 ft² · Sold $318K · Nov 2026
- 5835 Costino Ln$287K4 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,636 ft² · Sold Nov 2026
- 5702 Windmill Dr$201K3 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,925 ft² · Sold $206K · Nov 2026
- 5357 Spring Creek Cir$215K2 bd · 2 ba · 1,288 ft² · Sold $213K · Nov 2026
- 5149 Mccarty Ct$280K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,903 ft² · Sold $323K · Nov 2026
- 3981 Gateway Ct$66K3 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,368 ft² · Sold Nov 2026
- 5132 Tuscany Ln$181K2 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,567 ft² · Sold $179K · Nov 2026
- 4417 Dartmoor Dr$172K3 bd · 1,225 ft² · Sold $153K · Nov 2026
- 5228 Deer Creek Dr$343K4 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,034 ft² · Sold $336K · Nov 2026
- 5213 Lakeside Manor Dr$250K3 bd · 1 ba · 1,498 ft² · Sold $303K · Oct 2026
Assigned schools
Explore the area
See this home in context
Open 5440 Pillory Way on TopHap’s interactive map to compare it against every sale nearby, overlay school zones and flood risk, and run a CMA.
Open in map