Skip to content
Skip to content
TopHapOpen in map

Shelter Island 11964

ZIP codeThe kind of area this report covers. Neighborhood areas nest inside each other, from broad districts down to small pockets.New YorkBuyer's market
Market temperatureA 0 to 100 score comparing this area with every similar area nationwide each month. 0 is the strongest buyer's market, 100 the strongest seller's market.Buyer's market · 38
Buyer's marketBalancedSeller's market
$2.2M
Median sale priceThe middle sale price each month, counting normal open-market sales. The average runs above the median when a few expensive sales pull it up. Bars show how many homes sold.
+16.9%
1-yr changeHow much prices and sales counts changed since the same time last year, using a 3-month average to smooth out noise. Above the dashed line means growth.
36
Sales (12 mo)How many homes sold here in the last 12 months. More sales make the other numbers more reliable.
$2.1M
Median valueThe middle estimated value of all homes here, not just the ones that recently sold.

Deed records through Jul 2026 · Quarterly intervals (lower sales volume)Counties take time to publish deeds, so the newest months can be incomplete and may shift as more records arrive.

Market Trends

Market temperature (0–100)How the 0 to 100 market score moved over time. It blends price growth, sales pace, how often homes change hands, and seller profits.Temperature
20162018201920212022202320252026
Sale pricesThe middle sale price each month, counting normal open-market sales. The average runs above the median when a few expensive sales pull it up. Bars show how many homes sold.MedianSales
20162018201920212022202320252026
Growth (year over year)How much prices and sales counts changed since the same time last year, using a 3-month average to smooth out noise. Above the dashed line means growth.PriceSales
20162018201920212022202320252026
Price per square footThe middle price per square foot, for sales where the size is known. It adjusts for homes being different sizes.$/ft²
20162018201920212022202320252026
Sale premium vs estimated valueHow sale prices compare with our estimated values at the time of sale. Above the dashed line, homes sold for more than the models expected — a sign of competitive bidding. Below it, buyers paid under model value.Premium
20162018201920212022202320252026
Annual turnover (share of homes sold)The share of all homes here that sold in the trailing 12 months. Higher turnover means a more liquid market where homes trade hands more often.Turnover
20162018201920212022202320252026
Buyer mixWho is buying. Cash means no mortgage was recorded, investor means the buyer looked like an investor, and flip means the home resold within a year.CashInvestorFlip resale
20162018201920212022202320252026
Financing (share of purchase price)For buyers who borrowed: the middle share of the price they financed, and the middle share they paid up front.Loan (LTV)Down payment
20162018201920212022202320252026
Sellers who sold at a gainThe share of sellers each month who sold for more than they originally paid.Sold at gain
20162018201920212022202320252026
Typical hold before sellingThe middle number of years sellers owned their home before selling.Median hold
20162018201920212022202320252026
Median annualized return at resaleThe middle yearly gain sellers earned, spread across the years they owned the home. Only counts homes held at least a year.Annualized gain
20162018201920212022202320252026
Preforeclosure filingsForeclosure notices filed each month. A rise can be an early sign that more owners are struggling. Auction stage counts the filings that reached a scheduled foreclosure auction.FilingsAuction stage
20162017202120222023202420252026

Housing Stock

HomesHow many homes we have records for in this area.2,590
Median value (AVM)The middle estimated value of all homes here, not just the ones that recently sold.$2.1M
Median sizeThe middle home size here, measured in square feet.2,140 ft²
Median bedroomsThe middle bedroom count for homes here.3
Median year builtThe middle build year for homes here. A recent year means most housing is newer.1975
Single familyThe share of homes here that are single-family houses.98%

Equity & Ownership

Equity rich (LTV ≤ 50%)The share of owners who owe half or less of what their home is worth, meaning they hold a lot of equity.90%
Underwater (LTV ≥ 125%)The share of owners who owe at least 25% more than their home is worth.0.5%
Owner occupiedThe share of homes lived in by their owner rather than rented out or left empty.18%
Company ownedThe share of homes owned by a company or trust instead of a person.26%
Median loan-to-valueThe middle share of home value still owed on loans across all owners here.0%
Typical ownership tenureHow long the typical owner here has held their home.22.9 yrs

CommunityThese are comparison scores, not percentages. 100 equals the national average, so 150 means about 50% above average.

CrimeLocal crime compared with the rest of the country, where 100 is average. It reflects things like population density, income, and how crime gets reported.179
Air pollutionOverall air pollution compared with the rest of the country, where 100 is average. Lower is cleaner.105
EarthquakeEarthquake risk and likely building damage compared with the rest of the country, where 100 is average. Scores can run far above 100.49

Index scale: 100 = US average (tick). Lower is better.

Homes occupiedThe share of homes here that someone lives in. The rest sit empty, including vacation and for-sale homes.59%
Bachelor's or higherThe share of adults 25 and older whose highest degree is a bachelor's degree.32%
Poverty rateThe share of people whose household income falls below the federal poverty line, which varies by family size.7.0%
UnemploymentThe share of men 16 and older who are out of work and actively looking. Only men are counted in this figure.1.0%
PopulationHow many people live in this area.1,414
DensityPeople per square mile. Higher numbers mean a more crowded, urban area.146 / mi²
Median household incomeThe middle household income here — half of households earn more, half earn less.$104K
Average household incomeThe average household income. It runs higher than the median when a few high earners pull it up.$150K
Average tempThe average temperature here across a full year.51°F
Annual precipHow much rain and melted snow falls here in a typical year.47 in
SunshineThe share of daylight hours that get direct sun in a typical year, counting cloud cover.58%

Market metrics are derived from recorded arms-length deeds and refreshed nightly. Temperature blends price momentum, sales velocity, turnover and resale outcomes, ranked against all ZIP codes nationally.

How Shelter Island 11964 compares

By median home value, Shelter Island 11964 is the 11th most expensive of 104 ZIP codes in Suffolk County, and its typical home is worth more than 93% of all homes in Suffolk County.

Home values in Shelter Island 11964

Share of homes at each estimated value.

Median
$963K$10M
ZIP codes in Suffolk County ranked by median home value
#Suffolk CountyMedian valueHomes
1Sagaponack 11962$7.5M761
2Water Mill 11976$5.3M2,271
3Bridgehampton 11932$4.7M1,394
4Amagansett 11930$4.2M1,029
5Wainscott 11975$3.8M403
6Quogue 11959$2.6M969
7Southampton 11968$2.3M8,637
8Sag Harbor 11963$2.2M4,429
9Montauk 11954$2.1M2,948
10Fishers Island 06390$2.1M566
11Shelter Island 11964$2.1M2,590
12East Hampton 11937$2M8,772
13Cold Spring Harbor 11724$1.8M1,035
14Westhampton Beach 11978$1.8M1,961
15Remsenburg 11960$1.7M701
16Ocean Beach 11770$1.7M888
17Orient 11957$1.6M815
18Westhampton 11977$1.4M1,269
19East Quogue 11942$1.2M2,563
20East Marion 11939$1.1M976
21Great River 11739$1.1M383
22Cutchogue 11935$1M2,298
23Southold 11971$1M4,128
24Peconic 11958$999K557

104 ZIP codes in Suffolk County are ranked; the most valuable are listed here.

About the Shelter Island 11964 market

What is the median home price in Shelter Island 11964, NY?

The median sale price in Shelter Island 11964, NY is $2,240,000 (data through July 2026), based on deeds recorded with the county. That is up 16.9% from a year earlier.

How many homes sell in Shelter Island 11964, NY each year?

36 homes sold in Shelter Island 11964, NY over the last 12 months (data through July 2026). TopHap counts recorded arm's-length deeds, not listings, so the figure is not affected by which brokerage handled the sale.

Is Shelter Island 11964, NY a buyer's or seller's market?

Shelter Island 11964, NY is currently a buyer's market, scoring 38 out of 100 on TopHap's market temperature index (data through July 2026). The score weighs sales velocity and price direction; above 60 favours sellers, below 40 favours buyers.

How many homes are there in Shelter Island 11964, NY?

Shelter Island 11964, NY contains 2,590 residential properties, with a median of 2,140 square feet, 3 bedrooms, built around 1975. The median TopHap Estimate is $2.1M.

How does Shelter Island 11964, NY compare to the rest of Suffolk County?

By median home value, Shelter Island 11964, NY is the 11th most expensive of 104 ZIP codes in Suffolk County. Its typical home is worth more than 93% of all homes in Suffolk County. Fishers Island 06390 ranks just above it and East Hampton 11937 just below. The ranking is rebuilt nightly from the county assessor record of every home in each area.

Do people own or rent in Shelter Island 11964, NY?

18% of homes in Shelter Island 11964, NY are owner-occupied. 26% are held by a company rather than an individual.

How much equity do owners in Shelter Island 11964, NY hold?

90% of mortgaged homes in Shelter Island 11964, NY are equity-rich, meaning the loan balance is under half the home's value. 0.5% owe more than the home is worth.

Nearby markets

Browse addresses

Every street and address TopHap holds is browsable by state, county and city. Browse New York property records.

Explore Shelter Island 11964 on the map

See every recorded sale, price heat map, school zone and flood overlay across Shelter Island 11964 in TopHap’s interactive 3D map.

Open in map
A flyover of TopHap's photorealistic 3D map, with recorded sale prices pinned to homes
Search any address, city, zip, or county…3D$1.9M$6.25MOpen in map