?
  • Chat with Us
  • Submit Feedback
  • TopHap Academy
  • What's New?
Sign InSign Up Free

© 2025 TopHap. All rights reserved.

Residential > House
Off-Market
Sold Price
$--$--/ft²

25 Bay Shore Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • 3
    Beds
  • 4
    Baths
  • 2,774
    ft²
    Living Area
  • 0.7
    ac
    Lot Size
  • -
    Pool
  • 5
    Car
  • 1956
    Year Built
  • -
    DOM
  • -
    Permit
Malobo BannerMalobo Banner Square
25 Bay Shore Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964 is a 3 bed, 4 bath, 2,774 ft² house built in 1956 on a 0.700 acre lot. This house is currently off market. The latest TopHap estimate of the house's value is $3,904,380.

    Property Valuations

    Latest estimates for 25 Bay Shore Dr based on TopHap automated valuation model (AVM).

    • TopHap Estimate

      $3,904,380

      $1,407/ft²

      Updated 5 months ago

      • 25 Bay Shore Dr is valued at $3,904,380 by TopHap AVM 5 months ago.

    Current Ownership

    Information about the current owner(s).

    • Taxes Billed

      Total Assessed Value$2,132,000
      =
      Land
      Assessed Value      $1,002,000
      +
      Additions
      Assessed Value      $1,130,000

      • In 2020, taxes billed for 25 Bay Shore Dr were $0, which is 0.00% from latest Total Assessed Value of $2,132,000.

    Property History

    25 Bay Shore Dr has undefined property events records (listings, deeds, permits, tax, foreclosure, loan).

    Property Events

    Environment

    Environmental factors around 25 Bay Shore Dr

    • Hazard Risks

      Hurricane
      150
      Wind
      130
      Lead
      117
      Carb Mono
      112
      Ozone
      108
      Air Pollution
      105
      Nat'l Avg
      100
      Weather
      97
      Particulates
      82
      Earthquake
      49
      Hail
      27
      Tornado
      19

      • 12 hazards (Carbon Monoxide, Earthquake Risk, Hail Index, Tornado Index, Hurricane Index, Air Pollution Index, Ozone Index, Wind Index, Weather Risk, Lead Index, Particulate Matter, National Average) are above the national average around 25 Bay Shore Dr.

      Walkability Index

      9 /20

      Car Dependent

      Most Walkable

      20-18

      Very Walkable

      17-15

      Somewhat Walkable

      14-10

      Car Dependent

      9-0

      25 Bay Shore Dr has a walkability score of 9 out of 20, which means that it is in a car dependent area.

      Temperature

      Seasonal temperature sampled over multiple years

      Winter
      Average

      32 °F

      Low

      25°F

      High

      40°F

      Summer
      Average

      70 °F

      Low

      62°F

      High

      78°F

      In the winter at 25 Bay Shore Dr, temperatures range from 25.07°F to 39.89°F with an average of 32.48°F. In the summer, the temperature ranges from 61.85°F to 78.36°F with and average of 70.11°F.

    School Information

    Public/private schools serving 25 Bay Shore Dr

      Public Schools

      Shelter Island School
      Grades: PK-12
      1.51  mi
      C+
      * The school rating is based entirely on the test score performance of each school. It is based on a scale of A-F, A being best.

      Nearby public schools serving 25 Bay Shore Dr have ratings undefined.

    Neighborhood

    This property is located in Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY 11964.

      Crime Index for 11964

      188

      About 2 times the national average
      188

      The crime index in 11964 is 188, which is 1.9 times higher than national average.

    • Seasonal Housing units 11964

      91%

      of housing is for seasonal rent.

      Daytime Population for 11964

      +13%

      of people during work hours.

    Market Trends

    Historical market data near 25 Bay Shore Dr over selected time period.

    Nearby Properties on Bay Shore Dr

    USANYSuffolk CountyShelter IslandBay Shore-Dr