Residential > House
Active
10/07/2025
List Price
$776,900$148/ft²
301 Mcreynolds St
Carthage, NC 28327
- 5Beds
- 6Baths
- 5,246ft²Living Area
- 1acLot Size
- -Pool
- -Car
- 1880Year Built
- 92DOM
- -Permit
301 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 5 bed, 6 bath, 5,246 ft² house built in 1880 on a 1.040 acre lot. This house is currently on the market for $776,900, and it was last sold in 2019 for $358,500. The latest TopHap estimate of the house's value is $861,678.
Property Valuations
Latest estimates for 301 Mcreynolds St based on TopHap automated valuation model (AVM).
TopHap Estimate
$861,678
$170/ft²
+$85K above List Price
Updated 3 months ago
301 Mcreynolds St is valued at $861,678 by TopHap AVM 3 months ago.
MLS Description
The listing agent's description. Original Listing
Step back in time, yet stay luxuriously present. The Old Buggy Inn is more than a home - it's a living story, rich with Victorian elegance, historical character, and hospitality. Built in 1880 by W.T. Jones, this stately Queen Anne residence now welcomes guests as a fully operational boutique inn, blending original charm with modern comforts. With four distinct suites - each named after a Victorian-era carriage - the inn can host multiple parties while preserving privacy and intimacy. Guests linger in cozy common rooms, sip coffee on the wrap-around porch, or unwind in the beautifully landscaped garden. Each morning, they savor a gourmet breakfast, thoughtfully tailored from seasonal, local ingredients. The location is equally compelling. Just minutes from premier golf courses (including Pinehurst), yet set within a peaceful, small-town enclave, the inn offers effortless access to North Carolina's natural treasures: Uwharrie National Forest, Weymouth Woods, and more. This property offers dual appeal - for someone seeking a personal residence with character, or a turnkey hospitality venture in the heart of Moore County's tourism and leisure corridor.
Listing Agents
The listing agent for 301 Mcreynolds St is Ashley Leeah.
AL
Ashley Leeah
Carolina Property Sales
License: 303747
Phone: (910) 695-0001
Current Ownership
Information about the current owner(s).
Taxes Billed
Taxes billed in 2024$4,480.74From latest Total Assessed Value0.85%Total Assessed Value$525,600=Land+
Assessed Value$39,980Additions
Assessed Value$485,620
In 2024, taxes billed for 301 Mcreynolds St were $4,480.74, which is 0.85% from latest Total Assessed Value of $525,600.
Property History
301 Mcreynolds St has undefined property events records (listings, deeds, permits, tax, foreclosure, loan).
Property Events
Environment
Environmental factors around 301 Mcreynolds St
Hazard Risks
Hail270Hurricane217Wind169Weather145Carb Mono103Nat'l Avg100Particulates88Ozone87Air Pollution84Earthquake61Lead48Tornado35
12 hazards (Carbon Monoxide, Earthquake Risk, Hail Index, Tornado Index, Hurricane Index, Air Pollution Index, Ozone Index, Wind Index, Weather Risk, Lead Index, Particulate Matter, National Average) are above the national average around 301 Mcreynolds St.
Walkability Index
8 /20
Most Walkable
20-18
Very Walkable
17-15
Somewhat Walkable
14-10
Car Dependent
9-0
301 Mcreynolds St has a walkability score of 8 out of 20, which means that it is in a car dependent area.
Temperature
Seasonal temperature sampled over multiple years
Winter
Average
Low
32°F
High
55°F
Summer
Average
Low
66°F
High
89°F
In the winter at 301 Mcreynolds St, temperatures range from 31.7°F to 54.62°F with an average of 43.16°F. In the summer, the temperature ranges from 66.28°F to 88.92°F with and average of 77.6°F.
School Information
Public/private schools serving 301 Mcreynolds St
Public Schools
Union Pines High School
Grades: 9-12
4.59 mi
B
New Century Middle School
Grades: 6-8
3.96 mi
B-
Carthage Elementary School
Grades: PK-5
0.51 mi
A
* The school rating is based entirely on the test score performance of each school. It is based on a scale of A-F, A being best.
Nearby public schools serving 301 Mcreynolds St have ratings undefined, undefined, and undefined.
Neighborhood
This property is located in 28327.
Seasonal Housing units 28327
11%of housing is for seasonal rent.
Daytime Population for 28327
-24%of people during work hours.
Crime Index for 28327
90
90
The crime index in 28327 is 90, which is 0.9 times lower than national average.
Market Trends
Historical market data near 301 Mcreynolds St over selected time period.
Nearby Properties on Mcreynolds St
- 605 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 1,962 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.31 acre property. It was built in 1920 and has an estimate of $93,690 with a price per ft² of $48.
- 407 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,590 square foot, 4 bedroom, 2.25 bathroom, 1.54 acre property. It was built in 1925 and has an estimate of $309,320 with a price per ft² of $119.
- 601 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 1,724 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2.25 bathroom, 0.71 acre property. It was built in 1900 and has an estimate of $232,629 with a price per ft² of $135.
- 408 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 3,040 square foot, 5 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 0.82 acre property. It was built in 1905 and has an estimate of $447,100 with a price per ft² of $147.
- 308 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 (Magnolia Park) is a 2,742 square foot, 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 0.23 acre property. It was built in 1920 and has an estimate of $385,400 with a price per ft² of $141.
- 301 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 5,054 square foot, 5 bedroom, 6 bathroom, 1.04 acre property. It was built in 1880 and has an estimate of $641,706 with a price per ft² of $127.
- 602 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,067 square foot, 2 bedroom, 2.25 bathroom, 0.48 acre property. It was built in 1950 and has an estimate of $299,234 with a price per ft² of $145.
- 607 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 1,718 square foot, 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.64 acre property. It was built in 1959 and has an estimate of $241,737 with a price per ft² of $141.
- 609 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,936 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.63 acre property. It was built in 1920 and has an estimate of $376,000 with a price per ft² of $128.
- 611 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 3,436 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.89 acre property. It was built in 1910 and has an estimate of $357,445 with a price per ft² of $104.
- 701 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,028 square foot, 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 0.46 acre property. It was built in 1950 and has an estimate of $200,000 with a price per ft² of $99.
- 300 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 3,087 square foot, 5 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.59 acre property. It was built in 1830 and has an estimate of $288,149 with a price per ft² of $93.
- 306 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 3,417 square foot, 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.49 acre property. It was built in 1920 and has an estimate of $359,692 with a price per ft² of $105.
- 303 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,926 square foot, 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.56 acre property. It was built in 1916 and has an estimate of $303,850 with a price per ft² of $104.
- 710 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,380 square foot, 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.44 acre property. It was built in 1955 and has an estimate of $299,214 with a price per ft² of $126.
- 1005 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 (Brooklyn Heights) is a 2,008 square foot, 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 1.55 acre property. It was built in 1920 and has an estimate of $326,115 with a price per ft² of $162.
- 802 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 4,172 square foot, 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 2.33 acre property. It was built in 1927 and has an estimate of $531,704 with a price per ft² of $127.
- 501 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 4,182 square foot, 5 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 2.63 acre property. It was built in 1900 and has an estimate of $414,474 with a price per ft² of $99.
- 704 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 1,891 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.43 acre property. It was built in 1930 and has an estimate of $205,049 with a price per ft² of $108.
- 606 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 3,569 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 1.66 acre property. It was built in 1909 and has an estimate of $322,581 with a price per ft² of $90.
- 909 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 (Brooklyn Heights) is a 1,260 square foot, 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 0.51 acre property. It was built in 1947 and has an estimate of $94,000 with a price per ft² of $75.
- 803 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 (Brooklyn Heights) is a 2,574 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 6.67 acre property. It was built in 1920 and has an estimate of $433,849 with a price per ft² of $169.
- 506 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 2,569 square foot, 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 0.96 acre property. It was built in 1906 and has an estimate of $287,848 with a price per ft² of $112.
- 910 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 (Brooklyn Heights) is a 1,259 square foot, 3 bedroom, 2.28 acre property.
- 406 Mcreynolds St, Carthage, NC 28327 is a 3,140 square foot, 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 0.94 acre property. It was built in 1875 and has an estimate of $327,006 with a price per ft² of $104.
- View more properties on Mcreynolds St